Call with any questions! (608) 837-5662

Your Dream Ring Begins Here

Madison’s Premier Destination for Fine and Custom Jewelry

Explore our Process

The Perfect Ring Begins With The Perfect Experience

Our philosophy

See how our quality, expertise and process work together to bring your dream ring to life

Helping Madison Say “I Do” For over 40 Years

Looking for the perfect engagement ring to make your proposal unforgettable?

Browse our selection of engagement rings online or in-store and find the one that will make your partner say "yes" to a lifetime of love and commitment.

Sold out

Sold out

Sold out

Sold out

What we believe

Prairie Jewelers is your premier destination for custom-made one-of-a-kind jewelry. Whether you want to create a custom engagement ring or restore a family heirloom, we have the expertise to make your vision a reality.

As the new owner of Prairie Jewelers, I'm excited to continue providing our customers with exceptional service and high-quality jewelry. Our store has a comfortable, low-stress atmosphere where you can browse at your own pace and know that you're being treated with respect. Whether you're looking for a custom-made piece or a beautiful piece from our collection, we look forward to helping you find the perfect jewelry to celebrate life's special moments.

-Art Fish

Ready to Pop the Big Question?

Let us help you make it a moment your partner will never forget. Our carefully curated collection of engagement rings features stunning designs that will fit any budget. From simple elegance to bold statement pieces, we have the perfect ring for your proposal.

"All around, probably the best experience in a jewelry store that I've ever had. Art and Mike were awesome! So friendly and knowledgeable. They took time out of their busy day to help me with some old jewelry I was wanting to get rid of. They took the time to examine each piece (there was a lot) and we're 100% honest and transparent with me regarding pricing. I would recommend this place to anyone looking for a great and honest jewelry store. Will definitely be back. Thank you Art and Mike!"


"I had such a great experience working with Art! I wanted to upgrade the diamond in my wedding set and he worked with me to find the perfect stone within my budget. He even took the time to find a marquee stone that was the same ratio (length vs width) as my old stone too. End result was gorgeous and I've received many compliments!


"Designed the engagement and wedding bands of my dreams for a fraction of the price of other locations, highly recommend!


Shop Your Way: Online or In-Store!

Visit us at 976 W. Main St. Sun Prairie, WI 53590

If you can't find what you're looking for online or in-store. Talk to Art or Mike about creating a custom piece of jewelry or engagement ring. We work directly with the best in business and can get you the exact engagement ring you are looking for, or you can create something completely custom.